You asked, we built it: skip any box with fish you'd rather not eat

Post Type:
Guide
Time to read:
4 minutes

Since we started, one request has come up more than almost any other: “Can I tell you which fish I don't want?” We've heard it at signup, in our inbox, in DMs, and sometimes on the way out the door.

Starting now, you can. Tell us which categories you'd rather skip. If a month's box includes any of them, we'll skip that box for you automatically. On a monthly plan, you won't be charged for it. On a prepaid plan, you won't lose it.

Members and gift givers: set your preferences here. It takes about 30 seconds.

‍

What our signup survey told us

When you join, we ask which fish you're less excited about. That data made the case for this feature.

  • About 4 in 10 new members (39%) flag at least one category. The other 6 in 10 are happy with anything we send.
  • Most people flag only one. 31% of members name one category and 9% name two. Almost nobody names three or more.
  • The most common picks are close together: pâtés and spreads (18%), octopus, squid and shellfish (15%), and anchovies (14%).

In short, most of you are adventurous eaters. Those who aren't usually have one specific fish in mind, not a long list. That's exactly what a targeted skip can handle.

Lineup of tinned fish from a Tinned Fish Club box

What cancellation notes told us

We also read every note members leave when they cancel. Among comments about the boxes themselves, the most common theme is the opposite of a dislike: people want more variety. They want fewer repeats and more surprises.

That left us with two groups pulling in opposite directions:

  • The explorers want bolder, less familiar tins every month.
  • The cautious eaters love the club but dread opening a box built around the one fish they won't touch.

Until now, each bold pick risked letting down the second group, and each safe pick risked boring the first. Knowing your preferences lets us curate more adventurously without sending anyone a box they won't enjoy.

‍

How it works

  1. Tell us what to skip. Choose any of these: octopus, squid, mussels, clams, anchovies, or pâtés and spreads. We list each one separately so you only skip what you really don't want. Sardines, mackerel, tuna, salmon and other core fish aren't on the list.
  2. We plan ahead. Each box is set well before it ships. Around the 25th of the month before, we check that box against your list.
  3. If any tin matches, we skip that box and email you. You don't need to do anything.

What a skip means for your plan

  • Monthly: you aren't charged that month. Your next box arrives the following month.
  • Prepaid (3, 6 or 12 months): you still get every box you paid for. Your plan's end and renewal date moves back one month.
  • Gift: the gift giver can set preferences at checkout, and the recipient can set their own from their welcome email. If both do, the recipient's choices win. When a gift box is skipped, both get a short heads-up email.

A few details

  • Your first box always ships. Your welcome box is different from the monthly box, so preferences start with your second box.
  • This is for preferences, not allergies. If you have a fish or shellfish allergy, please don't rely on this feature to keep you safe.

A step toward boxes you'll love every month

This isn't full customization yet. Our long-term goal is a box every month built entirely from tins you like. We're not there yet, but skipping boxes you wouldn't enjoy is a real step in that direction.

It also helps us curate. The more we know about what you like, the more confidently we can bring in new and unusual tins for the explorers without surprising anyone else.

Existing members and gift givers: set your preferences here.

New members: you'll be asked when you sign up. Join the club.

‍

FAQ

Can I change my preferences later?

Yes. Fill out the form again or email hello@tinnedfishclub.com.

Will you tell me which fish triggered the skip?

No. We keep each box a surprise for everyone else, so we'll just let you know your box was skipped because of your preferences.

Can I get a skipped box anyway?

Yes. Just reply to your skip email before your box's charge or ship date, and we'll put it back.

Does this cost anything?

No. It's included with every plan.

The Tinned Fish Club

The world's best tinned fish, on your table every month.

Three curated tins from small canneries in Portugal, Spain, Denmark and beyond, with the recipes and maker stories that go with them.

✓
3 tins a month
✓
Exclusive recipes
✓
Cancel anytime
New members
Your first month gets a bonus tin
60% off your first box
with a 6+ month membership, code
SPLASH60
A Tinned Fish Club box with three tins of sardines, mussels and tuna, flatbread and spices
Guide
Skip the fish you don't like: Tinned Fish Club boxes with octopus, squid, mussels, clams, anchovies and pâtés as skippable options

New: Skip the fish you don't like

Tell us which fish you'd rather not get, and we'll skip any box that includes it. Here's how it works.
View Post
In the Box
Tinned Fish Club October 2026 box with La Barca octopus, Ramirez tuna with red beans and corn, King Oscar salmon and Rustic Bakery sourdough flatbread

Tinned Fish Club for October 2026

Find out what members received in October, 2026!
View Post
Guide
Miss Can and Manna mackerel in mustard on a slate board with crackers, tomatoes, cucumber, olives and pickled peppers

Our Tinned Fish Taste Test Results

Five friends, eleven tins, one clear set of winners. See the top 5 and every head-to-head.
View Post
Guide
Friends around a table scoring tinned fish on score sheets at a tasting party

How to Host a Tinned Fish Tasting Party

Score sheets, snacks and a step-by-step plan for your own tinned fish tasting night.
View Post