Since we started, one request has come up more than almost any other: “Can I tell you which fish I don't want?” We've heard it at signup, in our inbox, in DMs, and sometimes on the way out the door.
Starting now, you can. Tell us which categories you'd rather skip. If a month's box includes any of them, we'll skip that box for you automatically. On a monthly plan, you won't be charged for it. On a prepaid plan, you won't lose it.
Members and gift givers: set your preferences here. It takes about 30 seconds.
When you join, we ask which fish you're less excited about. That data made the case for this feature.
In short, most of you are adventurous eaters. Those who aren't usually have one specific fish in mind, not a long list. That's exactly what a targeted skip can handle.

We also read every note members leave when they cancel. Among comments about the boxes themselves, the most common theme is the opposite of a dislike: people want more variety. They want fewer repeats and more surprises.
That left us with two groups pulling in opposite directions:
Until now, each bold pick risked letting down the second group, and each safe pick risked boring the first. Knowing your preferences lets us curate more adventurously without sending anyone a box they won't enjoy.
This isn't full customization yet. Our long-term goal is a box every month built entirely from tins you like. We're not there yet, but skipping boxes you wouldn't enjoy is a real step in that direction.
It also helps us curate. The more we know about what you like, the more confidently we can bring in new and unusual tins for the explorers without surprising anyone else.
Existing members and gift givers: set your preferences here.
New members: you'll be asked when you sign up. Join the club.
Yes. Fill out the form again or email hello@tinnedfishclub.com.
No. We keep each box a surprise for everyone else, so we'll just let you know your box was skipped because of your preferences.
Yes. Just reply to your skip email before your box's charge or ship date, and we'll put it back.
No. It's included with every plan.
Three curated tins from small canneries in Portugal, Spain, Denmark and beyond, with the recipes and maker stories that go with them.




