Canned Fish or Tinned Fish: What's the difference?

Post Type:
Guide
Time to read:
3 minutes

Is it "Canned Fish" or "Tinned Fish?"

โ€

Over the last few years (and we would know!) seafood preserved in metal has skyrocketed in popularity. While this method of preserving and storing seafood has been around for over a century, it's only in the last few years where you'll find luxury sardines at your favorite wine bar.

โ€

And through that growth, a debate has emerged over what to call it! "Canned Fish" has perhaps been around the longest. Canning, after all, existed before the tin can. The method of preserving food by cooking it within a sealed a canister was invented in the early 1800s to preserve rations for war. The first canned goods were kept in glass jars!

โ€

Metal cans made from tin were put to use shortly thereafter. Even today, though, you might know someone who spends the day canning pickles or kimchi inside of glass mason jars.

Tinned fish, also known as canned fish
Canned fish and tinned fish are the same product

"Canned Fish" and "Tinned Fish" mean the same thing--Sorta.

โ€

Fast forward to the twenty-first century, and the debate continues. The long and the short of it is that all tinned fish is canned: That is, its preserved in a metal canister for a long shelf life. Of course, the tins are no longer made of tin. They're made out of steel. Round or rectangular, the shape doesn't matter.

โ€

Here at Tinned Fish Club, we (obviously) say "Tinned Fish" because that best captures the special history and culinary use that preserved sardines, mackerel, squid, tuna, and countless other types of seafood have at the cultural moment. A glass jar of anchovies or a plastic sleeve of smoked salmon is technically "canned fish"--preserved in a canister!--but those products feel a bit apart from the artisinal, sustainable, and wonderfully idiosyncratic world of tinned fish.

โ€

We could get into the rhetorical implications a bit deeper (and maybe we will one day) but we're sticking with Tinned Fish, and we invite you to join the club.

โ€

The Tinned Fish Club

The world's best tinned fish, on your table every month.

Three curated tins from small canneries in Portugal, Spain, Denmark and beyond, with the recipes and maker stories that go with them.

โœ“
3 tins a month
โœ“
Exclusive recipes
โœ“
Cancel anytime
New members
Your first month gets a bonus tin
60% off your first box
with a 6+ month membership, code
SPLASH60
A Tinned Fish Club box with three tins of sardines, mussels and tuna, flatbread and spices
Guide
Skip the fish you don't like: Tinned Fish Club boxes with octopus, squid, mussels, clams, anchovies and pรขtรฉs as skippable options

New: Skip the fish you don't like

Tell us which fish you'd rather not get, and we'll skip any box that includes it. Here's how it works.
View Post
In the Box
Tinned Fish Club October 2026 box with La Barca octopus, Ramirez tuna with red beans and corn, King Oscar salmon and Rustic Bakery sourdough flatbread

Tinned Fish Club for October 2026

Find out what members received in October, 2026!
View Post
Guide
Miss Can and Manna mackerel in mustard on a slate board with crackers, tomatoes, cucumber, olives and pickled peppers

Our Tinned Fish Taste Test Results

Five friends, eleven tins, one clear set of winners. See the top 5 and every head-to-head.
View Post
Guide
Friends around a table scoring tinned fish on score sheets at a tasting party

How to Host a Tinned Fish Tasting Party

Score sheets, snacks and a step-by-step plan for your own tinned fish tasting night.
View Post